Talk:Graia

Tempestus or Ultima?

Two points of view:

• Imperial Armour = Tempestus
• Codex: Tyranids (3rd and 4th editions) = Ultima (cf. Kraken fleet's path)

So = is this an error or are we needed a disambiguation's page? --Ackheron 10:25, 28 October 2012 (CET)

Depends on what it's said in the two sources...Could you post a few quotes?--Ashendant 11:30, 28 October 2012 (CET)

IA pg 8 ="Segmentus Tempestus. Homeworld to the legio Astrana (Morning Stars).

Codices Tyranids: V4 pg.4 = "meanwhile,orbital defences on Graia" + "eastern Fringes" + near to the Ichar System.

Space Marine video game's cinematic intro = first zoom on the Galaxy map show the position of Graia at the east-frontier of Ultramar's kingdom. --Ackheron 11:42, 28 October 2012 (CET)

In that case, i think we should add a big note in the bottom describing those problems, since we are not sure if they are the same world or not.--Ashendant 14:21, 28 October 2012 (CET)

Yes, I think so. IMHO = The error don't came from THQ but from the autor of the Codex Tyranid's 3rd edition. The quote in the IA was just a little "detail", but since GW has build this face-off legend between Maccrage/Tyranid fleets, Graia sprang a couple of thousand light-years at once.. :) Can you make the note? --Ackheron 19:19, 28 October 2012 (CET)

Normally the last publication (most recent) takes precedence. However yes, a note would definitely be required. Probably we should also introduce some kind of tag for "canon conflicts" and such. --Inquisitor S., Großmeister des Ordo Lexicanum 14:31, 29 October 2012 (CET)

Sources misunderstanding

• The problem is more complicate and there is enough differences among the sources for both side (Tempestus/Ultima/legio)
  • the 2 Graia-articles must be splitted. See the thread on the forum.