Talk:Battle of Calth

Comparison with the W40k wiki's article

There's no question in my mind that the similar article on the WH40k wiki is more detailed than this one, most of which I wrote. Also, having read Know No Fear, I can see that most of the detail in that article, though uncited, is accurate. It should be possible for me to include that level of detail (though I think the other author went overboard in giving a second-by-second account of the battle), with proper sourcing. Stylistically, how does the current article read? Tedious? Thorough? Not thorough enough? Reactions would be welcome.--Proteus77 20:33, 30 May 2012 (CEST)

First of all, I like the article, good job. Secondly, I'm hesitant to talk about 40Kwiki's work even when it's good, as they ripped off a huge chunk of stuff we did here (they still do now and again, it's hilarious) and seem to be obsessed with some sort of weird competition between us that only exists on their end; I prefer to just ignore them and concentrate on making the lex articles as good as I want them to be/can be bothered making them. Which brings me to my last point; if you will find it fun and interesting to make this article more detailed, go for it. If it feels like it would be a drag or a chore, don't bother and do something else for a while. I'm sorry, that's probably not the kind of comment you're looking for at all. The article is great, reads well, covers everything. Sure, you could make it more detailed, but there's not a need to. The subject will probably be expanded in future material, so I imagine you'll want to revisit it then anyway?--Mob 14:33, 3 June 2012 (CEST)

Thanks. :-)--Proteus77 04:32, 4 June 2012 (CEST)

Legio Mortis was In combat on the battle of Calth in Know No Fear (Novel) so I ask that someone put it in the list of combatants, and a few cultist brotherhoods as well.-Shadowcat1 7:53 pm CST 4/24/2013

Sure thing, but I need a source stating it was Legio Mortis. I'm plugging through Know No Fear right now, but it never gives a specific Titan Legion that augmented the Word Bearer forces. -Yozzy